Manchester United's potential Erik ten Hag replacement, ft. Xavi, Ruben Amorim

Manchester United's managerial search begins as Erik ten Hag exits, ending a challenging tenure. With Ruud van Nistelrooy as interim, top candidates like Xavi, Gareth Southgate, and Ruben Amorim have emerged, bringing fresh hope to Old Trafford.

In Short

• Erik ten Hag left after a turbulent stint at Manchester United
• Ruud van Nistelrooy was appointed interim manager for stability
• Xavi, Southgate, and Amorim in contention as Ten Hag’s successors

As Erik ten Hag steps down as Manchester United manager, the focus has swiftly shifted to his potential successor. After a turbulent tenure that saw inconsistent results, Ten Hag ultimately decided to leave on his own terms, ending widespread speculation about his departure. United's confirmation of Ruud van Nistelrooy as interim head coach has sparked additional curiosity, with the former United striker now viewed as a contender for the full-time position.

With Ten Hag leaving, and United beginning their search for a permanent manager, the list of potential replacements, includes a mix of high-profile and promising candidates, each offering a distinct style and tactical approach. Amongst those reportedly in the running are former Barcelona manager Xavi, Sporting CP's Ruben Amorim, and ex-England manager Gareth Southgate. Each of these potential hires brings their own strengths, but also raises questions about their fit within United's current framework and goals.

Xavi

The prospect of Xavi taking the reins at United has gained traction recently, fueled by social media images of his son wearing a United jersey. Xavi’s tenure with Barcelona was marked by success, guiding the club to a La Liga title in his first year. Known for his possession-based, high-pressing style, Xavi’s approach emphasizes controlled, strategic football. However, with limited experience outside of Barcelona, some question whether his methods would suit the Premier League’s intensity. Nonetheless, his success with Barca’s rebuild makes him a standout candidate.

Gareth Southgate

Recently available after his exit as England manager, Gareth Southgate’s name has also surfaced as a possible replacement for Ten Hag. Southgate’s run with England was notable, reaching back-to-back European Championship finals, though his conservative style often drew criticism. His approach relied on individual talents rather than cohesive team play, which has raised doubts among United fans and analysts about his suitability for the role. While Southgate’s extensive international experience would be an asset, his track record of cautious tactics could be a misfit for United’s aggressive aspirations.

Ruben Amorim

Amongst the less conventional choices, Sporting CP’s Ruben Amorim stands out for his tactical depth and impressive achievements. Amorim has enjoyed success in the Portuguese league, leading Sporting CP to the Primeira Liga title in 2020-21 and 2023-24, along with earning manager of the year honors in his debut season. His pragmatic, off-the-ball holding tactics align well with United’s current squad depth and could bring a refreshing dynamic to the Premier League. Amorim’s experience, though limited outside Portugal, offers a potential blend of defensive solidity and transitional play that many believe would suit United.

While van Nistelrooy will lead in the interim, United’s final decision will ultimately shape the club’s direction. Each of these candidates brings a different philosophy and level of experience, making the choice crucial for reestablishing United’s competitive edge. Fans are eager to see who will take the helm and usher in a new era at Old Trafford.